Welcome to Atlantic Bagel Company - Atlantic Highlands
Our Atlantic Highlands location is situated in the heart of this charming coastal borough, just a short stroll from the Municipal Harbor where the high-speed ferry docks. We are nestled near the scenic hills of Mount Mitchill Scenic Overlook, offering breathtaking views of the New York City skyline. Residents from the nearby Leonardo and Highlands neighborhoods often stop by after a morning walk along the Bayshore Trail or a visit to the historic Twin Lights State Historic Site.
We’re Located in Atlantic Highlands
Address: 74 First Avenue, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716 Phone: 732-872-7727
Hours of Operation:
Mon – Sun: 6:00 AM – 2:00 PM
Fresh Bagels and Classic Favorites
Bagels are kettle boiled and baked the old fashioned way every day. The menu includes bagels, coffee, breakfast sandwiches, and deli sandwiches made with BOAR’S HEAD cold cuts. Homemade cream cheese and salads add variety while keeping the menu focused and easy to enjoy.
Freshness & Coastal Charm
Unmatched Freshness in Every Bite Our Atlantic Highlands patrons consistently celebrate the exceptional quality of our kettle-boiled bagels, frequently describing them as a "coastal gem." Sentiment analysis reveals high praise for our diverse topping selections and the welcoming, neighborly atmosphere. Visitors often highlight our shop as a must-visit for commuters, citing our attentive service and the reliable freshness of our signature breakfast sandwiches.
Easy Online Ordering
Ordering from Atlantic Bagel Company is quick and convenient. Guests can choose delivery, takeout, or dine in based on what works best. Online ordering helps save time during busy mornings and lunch hours, making it easy to enjoy fresh bagels without long waits.
📸 Fresh Bagels, Coffee, and More
Fresh bagels, coffee, and sandwiches are made daily. Everything is prepared to enjoy on the go or at the shop.
Catering Made Simple
Atlantic Bagel Company offers catering for meetings, events, schools, and family gatherings. Catering includes fresh bagels, breakfast items, and deli sandwiches prepared with care. Early hours and dependable service make catering a smart choice for groups of any size.
Visit Us or Order Today 📍
Atlantic Bagel Company is open daily from 6am to 2pm and ready to serve. Stop in for fast service, place a takeout order, or choose delivery for added convenience. Fresh bagels, classic sandwiches, and friendly service are always waiting.
What our guests are saying
One of those delis you only get in the tri-state area. Fresh bread daily, Boars Head meats, and a staff that knows how to build proper sandwiches for hungry working folk And responding to the other reviews - I get egg sandwiches and bagels here semi-regularly and I’ve never had problems, only deliciousness
Scrappy P.
Solid place for breakfast and lunch. The turkey Smokey is a great sandwich to share!
Robert T.
This is our must-go-to place every time we are in Atlantic Highlands. All of the food, including the bagels and toppings, are always super fresh, flavorful, and reasonably priced. The staff is very friendly, and one can tell how beloved it is in the community because everybody knows everybody’s name. A toasted everything bagel with white fish spread and a cup of cold brew cannot be beat!
Christian Z.
Featuring
Catering
Delivery
Takeout
Dine In
Vegan Options
Atlantic Bagel Company Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Deli Sandwiches, Croissants, Breakfast Sandwiches, Eggs, Salad, Pancakes, French Toast, Breakfast, Chicken Salad, Philly Cheesesteak, Cheesesteak, Bagel, Blt, Bacon, Hot Coffee, Rainbow Bagel, Cold Brew, Grilled Cheese, Salads, Coffee, Sausage, Omelet, Rainbow Bagels, Fries, Pastries, Vegetarian Food, Soup, Burritos, Hot Chocolate, Croissant, Tea, French Fries, Caesar Salad, Cappuccino, Sandwiches, Cake, Soups, and Iced Coffee
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Atlantic Highlands, Leonardville, Navesink, Hilton, Leonardo, Stone Church, Middletown, Locust, Monmouth Hills, Chapel Hill, Waterwitch, Belford, Highlands, Oceanic, New Monmouth, Fair Haven, Port Monmouth, Town Brook, Rumson, East Keansburg.
